Three reasons to make homemade maple vanilla marshmallows that might surprise you. You are probably wondering why you would make homemade marshmallows vs. simply buying some from the store?

First, homemade marshmallows melt better and have more flavor than anything store-bought. They are great for s’mores or hot chocolate. Or if you want to make rice crispy treats, the maple and vanilla add a nice pop of flavor.

Secondly, the marshmallow recipe calls for gelatin. Gelatin is incredibly good for your gut health. In fact, gelatin absorbs water and helps keep fluid in the digestive tract promoting healthy, regular bowel movements.

Homemade Maple Vanilla Marshmallows - Healthyish Foods

The third and final reason is because gelatin also promotes healthy skin. Glycine and proline are two amino acids used by our bodies to produce collagen.

And if this isn’t enough to convince you, homemade maple vanilla marshmallows simply look prettier and are fluffier than anything store-bought. So, get your mixers ready and start making this tasty recipe today. 

Looking for more dessert recipes? Try my cranberry cheese roll-ups or my Dutch apple cake.

Healthyish Brownies with Homemade Maple Marshmallows - Healthyish Foods
Homemade Maple Vanilla Marshmallows - Healthyish Foods

Homemade Maple Vanilla Marshmallows

No ratings yet
Leave a Review »


  • 1 cup cold water split into two
  • 3 tablespoons unflavored gelatin
  • 1 cup light maple syrup
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla flavor
  • Powdered sugar for dusting


  • sauce pot
  • mixer
  • loaf pan


  • Grease a loaf pan with baking spray.
  • Pull out your mixer with the wire whisk attachment.
  • Combine gelatin, vanilla and ½ cup cold water in the mixing bowl. Allow it to sit in the bowl.
  • Combine maple syrup and ½ cup cold water in a medium saucepan and bring to a boil.
  • Use a thermometer to make sure the maple syrup water mixture reaches 240°. This should take about 10ish minutes.
  • Once desired temperature is reached, slowly and carefully pour heated mixture into the gelatin and water mixture while slowly increasing the speed of the mixer.
  • After about 5-8 minutes your marshmallow mixture should start to resemble marshmallow fluff. Once this happens, turn off your mixer.
  • Quickly pour marshmallow mixture into your greased loaf pan and spread evenly. If it is hard to spread the marshmallows you can microwave the mixture for 20 seconds, This will soften the mixture and make it spreadable again.
  • Cover with saran wrap and refrigerate for 30-40 minutes before cutting into cubes.
  • Once you are ready to cut the marshmallows, dust your cutting surface with powdered sugar. This will prevent the marshmallow from sticking to the surface.
  • Dust the marshmallows again once they are all cut into cubes.
  • Serve immediately and enjoy!
    Store covered in the frig for up to 3 days. May need to dust with powdered sugar again before using.